← All episodes
Episode artwork
Konesans SeriesEp. 5616 minMay 31, 2023

Dr. Kaiama Glover explains Spiralism: A Uniquely Haitian Way of Looking & Expressing the World

0:00–:––

Key points

  • Kaiama L. Glover explains that Frankétienne, Jean-Claude Fignolé and René Philoctète saw spiralism as a tool and a process that resists rigid definition.
  • She ties the spiral to Haitian material life: the conch shell of revolt, the shape of hurricanes, and the movement around the poto mitan in the peristil.
  • Glover describes reading spiralist novels through character, time and space, and form, guided by the spiral's balanced tension and its repetition with a difference.
  • She argues that refusing binaries lets Haiti be exceptional and still relatable, and calls spiralism a Haitian proposition for reading the world.

Through our art & religion, there is definitely a Haitian way of viewing & expressing how we engage with the world. Dr. Kaima Glover explains Spiralsm.

Transcript

1,641 words · 7 min read

Machine transcript. Names and Kreyòl words may be misspelled. Tap a time to play from there. Also on Jou.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste What is spiralism? You said something that struck me that is distinctly a Haitian literary phenomenon. How so?

Kaiama Glover In a number of ways. So your first question is, what is it? One of the most important things about spiralism is its reluctance to be defined in a rigid way. I think that's something that Fonc-Étienne in particular, but also Fignolet, Jean-Gloup Fignolet and René Filoctet were adamant about, which is that spiralism was a tool and a process. And an offering, an approach to the world, not a definition of a thing. So it does have this sort of open-endedness that can feel maybe frustrating or unsettling, I guess you would say, for intellectuals or for people even like myself, right, whose job it is to kind of categorize and define things. But spiralism really asks that we question that instinct and that we allow for a greater open-endedness that is defiant of rigid frames, boundaries of inside and outside. But as to what makes it specifically Haitian or why it makes sense that spiralism emerged from the Haitian context, in my book and in conversation with Fonc-Étienne, which is a large part of my understanding of spiralism, I try to get to the fact that it has real material connections to Haitian history and culture. And that's everything from the spiral of the conch shell, which is so symbolic of revolution and rallying and revolt that is part of the DNA of Haitian culture. Also thinking more broadly about, and this is something that is coming up for us right now, the actual literal shape of the hurricanes that plague and endanger Caribbean peoples and people of the global South more broadly. In Frank-Étienne's time and the spiralist time, but into our present moment. So those sort of spiraling images in nature. And then also the spiral of the encircling of the spiraling, I shouldn't say encircling, the spiraling around the pot d'homitant in the Paris-Île of the Rhumphore. These are all very material, explicit iterations of the spiral in the Haitian built environment and in the Haitian natural environment that I think the spiralists were trying to harness in their literature.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste This is what you meant by a tradition of regional self-creation, right?

Kaiama Glover Very much so.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Yeah.

Kaiama Glover Very much so. I think, you know, part of the reason I was so interested in spiralism is, you know, as a scholar and as a person of Caribbean descent and person of African-American descent, I'm always really most interested in epistemologies and in frames that are meaningful to the world beyond their context, but are also idiosyncratically anchored in their context, right? So the ways in which the Caribbean and Haiti in particular have pushed back against definitions that come from the outside. And I think spiralism is one of the richest and most productive offerings in that respect.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste So is there, it sounds like you were careful because you were, it seems like you were very conscious of it. Like you didn't want to impose too much of a structure on something that fights structure, right? Right. So how did you strike that balance between, you don't want it to be too theoretical for some, you know, outputs that challenges or escapes from that sort of imposition, you know, academic imposition or theoretical, intellectual imposition. How did you strike that balance?

Kaiama Glover Yeah. It was a combination, I think, of a couple of methodological approaches. Just the first was, all right, so thinking about how to put the book together, I was like, well, what are the elements of narrative that undergird any novel, any piece of literature and the spiralist literature in particular? And I just kind of narrowed that down to character, time and space and formal strategies. And so I decided, all right, so at least I can identify these three kind of building blocks of the novel that I can look at as separate, related, but separate entities. So what do these spiralist novels tend to do with character? What do they tend to do with the manipulation of time and space, of history and the environment? And then what do they tend to do with various formal elements, language, stylistics, structure? So that was the first method, I guess you'd say I used, which was, like I said, this kind of breaking down the novels into their composite parts. And then the second element was really taking very seriously the spiral as a hermeneutic, the spiral as the tool that would enable me to better understand these novels. So it meant understanding for me, like what does that spiral form do? Like as a metaphor for me as a reader, what are some of the basic principles that are inherent in the form of a spiral? And so, you know, notions of tension was one of the biggest ones, right? Like unresolved tension, because if a spiral functions, it's because of this perfectly balanced tension between centripetal force and centrifugal force. Otherwise, it would collapse in on itself or would spin out and destroy itself. So how do I see tension running through the way the characters are presented, how time and space are deployed, how words and sounds are used in the spiralist narratives? Another element of the spiral for me that was important was the idea of repetition with a difference. So the idea that in all of these three elements, again, character, type and space, style, how do the spiralists bring back the recognizable and the familiar in ways that reassure a reader while then departing ever so slightly from those things so as to unsettle the reader? So that was another element. Like how does the spiral itself provide a guide for approaching my readings? So those were the two things. I felt like if I slash a reader could get a hold of that shape and get a hold of those narrative building blocks, then the novels became comprehensible. Comprehensible.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Haitian exceptionalism. And one breath, I hear, yes, Haiti is unique, X, Y, Z. And in another breath, it's because of the exceptionalism that all these other exclusionary things like being kept from the cannon and, you know, on and on. How to solve some of the more, you know, entrenched issues that are going on politically and socially in the country. So where do you stand in terms of Haitian exceptions? I'm beginning to think it's a double-edged sword.

Kaiama Glover Yeah, I think the best way out of that potential conundrum is to understand, first of all, that several things can be true at once. One. And two, I would say to recognize how useless binaries can be, right? That some person or some space is all good or all bad. And the thing about refusing binaries is that you have to work harder. You have to look for nuance. You have to actually get information, digest it, process it, and think it all the way through. Black and white is much easier, right? Right, right. To be as extreme or extremely heroic or extremely victimized. And if you and the West as evil and predatory or as enlightening and helpful, right? Those things, all of those things can be true at once. And the bonus is on us, certainly as scholars, but I would say as citizens, like global citizens, to claw our way out of those boundaries and those binaries and to recognize, yeah, Haiti's exceptional. But that doesn't mean that it's also not relatable and understandable in the ways any other human community would be.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste So is spiralism a way out of that? I think it's helpful.

Kaiama Glover I think that spiralism, to me, the beauty and the marvel of spiralism is that it proposes a way of looking at the world that is idiosyncratically Haitian, yes, but that also is capacious and expansive enough to be useful to thinking other places. And the spiral form is, you know, I write about this, it's just this incredibly banal geometric form that everyone literally has access to that is literally the shape of our universe, of our DNA, of the shells that wash up on the beach, right? It's this ubiquitous universal form. But it also has this incredibly beautiful and metaphoric place in Haitian history. It's the spiral of the conch shell that is held by the Negmaum, right? It is the spiral of the tropical storms and the cyclones that hit the Caribbean region in particular. And it's this really beautiful way, I think, that these three authors have come to understand almost like the one step or the two steps forward, one step back movement of Haiti's history throughout the 19th, 20th and 21st century, right? This, like history repeating itself with a difference. This notion that progress is happening, but not without a reckoning with the past, that the present and the future are so bound up in that past that you need to come to terms with it in order to exist in the present and imagine the future. So I love spiralism because it's a Haitian proposition for a way of reading the world. Lak 不是

Patrick Jean-Baptiste The beat on you Frappe The beat on you Frappe Bagapala The beat on you Frappe The beat on you Frappe Bagapala The beat on you Ibo The beat on you Congo The beat on you Petro The beat on you Bagapala The beat on you Frappe The beat on you ! The beat on you Bagapala The beat on you Frappe The beat on you Frappe The beat on you Frappe Bagapala The beat on you Ibo The beat on you Ibo

Oh

Patrick Jean-Baptiste benutzony Iwa Iwa, Iwa Iwa, Iwa Iwa Iwa Nisuméo Baby, tambou frappe Bagapala

Ayyayay

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Baby, tambou frappe Bagapala manifestation Meanwhile Oh