← All episodes
Episode artwork
Scholar SeriesEp. 8076 minOct 23, 2026

The First and Last King of Haiti: The Rise and Fall of Henry Christophe

A conversation with Dr. Marlene Daut
0:00–:––

Key points

  • Dr. Marlene Daut wrote a full life of Henry Christophe, and in it she says who is speaking in every source, his enemies included, so readers can weigh conflicting accounts themselves.
  • She spells his name Henry, as the king himself did, a royal form shared with the kings of France. Born in Grenada, he served as a youth with the free men of color at the Battle of Savannah in 1779.
  • His wife, Marie-Louise Coidavid, signed colonial documents under another surname, Malgrin.
  • In 1802 Christophe rejoined the French and sent his eldest son to school in France; after independence the boy was thrown out and died destitute in Paris.
  • Under Dessalines he ran celebrations, schools, courts, hospitals and the building of the Citadelle Henry. Daut sets the word "massacre" in quotation marks for 1804, since the French were drowning prisoners in 1802 and using dogs in 1803.
  • Crowned king on 2 June 1811, Christophe refused to deal with French envoys who would not call Haiti by its name or who asked for money, while Pétion offered to pay. Daut calls him a complicated anti-hero.

Born in Grenada, a youth at the Battle of Savannah, the general who set Cap-Français on fire as Leclerc arrived, then King of the North. Dr. Marlene Daut talks about her biography of Henry Christophe. She covers what is known and what is guessed about his origins, his friendship and break with Capois-La-Mort, and the French plot to set him against Pétion. She also covers the free press and culture of his kingdom. At the heart of it is one question: what path did Haiti lose after Christophe's death and the indemnity?

Read the full transcript on Jou: https://jou.rasanblaj.ht/podcast/neg-mawon/2027-04-12/transcript

Transcript

12,250 words · 53 min read

Machine transcript. Names and Kreyòl words may be misspelled. Tap a time to play from there. Also on Jou.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste You've been dizzy

Marlene Daut Yeah Definitely

Patrick Jean-Baptiste So we're here now And I finished it

Marlene Daut Oh my goodness

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Although a book like that Can you ever really finish it Right

Marlene Daut I mean I ask myself that every day

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Yeah I remember Reading somewhere That Some books I think The quote was Some books aren't projects They're more creatures That grow With you Do you share that sentiment?

Marlene Daut Oh I mean Absolutely I mean I'm thinking of Starting a newsletter Called King Henry's World About all this stuff I cut out It's hard to believe There's things that I cut out of there But So many different things That were just like Side streets But completely fascinating So Yeah

Patrick Jean-Baptiste I'm going to read something You said That Fascinated me about Since I've read so many Of your books And this journey We've been on Having you on the show That I was like Is this a new Malena That I'm seeing Is this a new voice This is what she said Quote In telling the story Of the very life Of Henry Christophe Father and son Brother and friend Husband and soldier Slave and king I have tried To hew As closely as possible To narratives From the king himself His family members His allies And those who Personally knew him Or claimed to have Regardless of their Ultimate feelings And conclusions About him At times I felt Forced To rely on The accounts Of his enemies But Breaking with the Ordinary tradition Of the biographer Who possessed Silent judgment On the reliability Of sources I also felt it Necessary to use My voice To intervene To provide Context And background To help the reader Understand The relationship Between the chronicler And the subject Of the chronicle End of quote So two key phrases That stuck out For me in that quote That to me Speaks Varmus about You know Maybe the role Of the historian And activism If that's the proper word Maybe I go too far The two phrases are You felt forced To rely On the account Of his enemies And I also felt It necessary To use my voice To intervene You seem unapologetic About this sort of More dimension To this book That I'm seeing Am I not reading it right Or it seems Markedly different From other things You've written

Marlene Daut Yeah absolutely I mean It's interesting I was just at The American Historical Association conference Over the weekend And our panel Was called Biographies of Resistance The Ethics of Documenting Haitian Lives And the other panelists Were Julia Gaffield Who's about to publish A biography of Jean-Jacques Desalines Robin Mitchell Who's working on A biography of Suzanne Vulture And Kayama Glover Who is writing A biography of René DeFeste

Patrick Jean-Baptiste And so we were

Marlene Daut Talking about You know the idea Of the biographer Who is this Objective truth teller Is really It's not possible Not just in these cases But in any of the cases Right But so many Biographers Don't necessarily Share that opinion And I knew that Because to prepare For this book Since I had never Written a biography Like this before A cradle to grave Biography of somebody I was reading Lots of biographies And I was actually Astonished At the level Of You know I tried to read Biographies about People I at least Knew something about Right And to see Biographers Just in the I'd follow the footnote Oh I'm curious About that And to see No mention Of the conflicting Accounts To see that The biographer Seems to have Just decided And not revealed To the reader Based on what Evidence What their evidence Was for that decision Which may have been A good decision May have been The right decision But impossible To verify Unless you are A subject matter Expert And you Already know But for For a reader Who's not an expert In that figure They need to know That there are Conflicting accounts Because other Wives when they Read something That contradicts What they wrote What readers When readers Come to an account That contradicts What a biographer Says They will have No way to judge Which of those Accounts They should rely on So we need to know Who's doing the talking What's their Motive What's their point of view What are they hoping To accomplish And so that's The moral and ethical I think dimension That I'm glad Comes through in the work Because that's exactly What it was

Patrick Jean-Baptiste The first paragraph In this book Is about terminology You talk a little bit About the spelling Of King Christor's First name Louvertures And some of his Other contemporaries What was that What was that important For you to start there

Marlene Daut You know This is This is so interesting At least to me Because you know Since I write a lot About The King In various realms Including for You know Newspapers and magazines You probably Couldn't believe The number of editors Who have tried To correct me Over the years And tried to And in fact In some cases You know They I didn't get to see The final round of edits Sometimes that happens It just appears And I see that All the Henry's With a Y Have been changed To Henry With an I So I have found That I needed To explain to the reader That this is not You know Or I've had editors Ask me Why are you spelling His name the British way Which Henry With a Y Is not the British way It's a royal honorific Like the King Henry Of France Spelled his name With a Y It's not the British spelling But that's a common belief And King Henry Always spelled his own name With a Y So I'm not going to Change it to an I Although I'm not I don't feel strongly I don't think it's wrong For people to do so It occurred during his lifetime As well When others wrote about him It's sort of like L'ouverture with an apostrophe Or without an apostrophe I'm not going to You know It's not a cross to die on But I did want the reader To know why I Made that Not really made that decision But just followed That path I guess I'd say

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Here's something else You wrote In Suicide Christophe could control His destiny But he couldn't control His legacy Can you talk You mentioned that A little bit Can you talk about He's being portrayed Simultaneously With You said Wonder and disdain Yeah But mostly disdain By his rivals And enemies Obviously Right You quoted his friend Wilberforce Who said To Christophe I cannot help Grieving At the idea Of his characters Being left to the dogs And vultures To devour I love that So out of everything You've read From Christophe's Rivals and enemies If you were to put them In sort of a word cloud Engine What are some key words Would you imagine Would stand out Above the rest

Marlene Daut Oh wow Christophe was a visionary But of course He's a flawed man As are all human beings He's a flawed character He's troubled And the reason That I would say You know In that word cloud Alongside visionary And leader And revolutionary And radical And abolitionist And anti-slavery activist And freedom fighter And father and son And all of these things So many things Right That I would say We have to go back To the earliest years And I say that because When I first began To conceive of this story I thought I'm going to write About Christophe And the king of Haiti It's not going to be A cradle to grave biography Which is what it ended up being Because I thought That part of the story That we needed Most illuminating about Was the kingdom That there were books That were just about The kingdom of Haiti But I realized After reading All of the enemy reports That both During his lifetime And immediately Afterward especially That if we want To understand This person Then we need To understand What happened To this person All along Right Because even if Somebody comes away From reading my book And say I would add the word Monster to Christophe Or Tyrand I think those Accounts were correct Even if so Then they would need To understand Well how did that happen Because this is not A sociopath This is not A person Who has an Antisocial personality disorder This is a person Who was a child Who grew up In brutal Horrific environments And saw things That most human beings Will never see Even if they live To be 110 And to think That a person Could walk away From like The battle of Savannah Which is extremely violent And where he was wounded And where he saw people Dying and shot All around him And not be affected By it And to go To Saint-Domingue From there To the cruelest Slave colony In the world Whether or not He was ever enslaved On that particular island To see the things He saw during the revolution And to come out of that And say I believe in humanity And I want to create This beautiful society And sure He doesn't have The best methods And doesn't necessarily Know how to do that But the idea That someone Could suffer In that way And still believe I find that fascinating And I find it visionary And I don't know That there are many people Who have that type of Strength and fortitude To be honest

Patrick Jean-Baptiste I haven't released That episode Yes With Chris Bungie But I think You guys have Some different perspective On Vate Do you trust Vate As an authoritative source On Christophe Giving his position In the kingdom I

Marlene Daut Yes Because every It depends on What you mean By authoritative He's of course Subjective and biased But I find it fascinating That that's even a question Every single person is And that's what I mean When I say I intervene to say This is Christophe's Right hand man For lack of a better term This is his personal secretary This is his ride or die But Who is not Who turns on him Just Charlotte And Julien Prévost So the idea That there Being a turncoat Makes them more reliable To me Well no Depending on According to whom Because Jus Charlotte Is someone Who I talk about In the book As you know He's Serves under Desamin And then he Kind of You know I would say Turns on him But you know Not as favorable Towards him Then he works Under Christophe And then he goes And works under Bollier Who he's just been Like spending His entire career You know Essentially defaming On behalf of Of the king And so the idea That This person Jus Charlotte Who after The indemnity Is signed Like celebrates It and says The king of France is the True liberator Of the Haitian People The idea That he Would be More trustworthy ! Or that any Of these Other figures Who grew Critical of the King after His death Are more Are we Should trust Them more Because of That criticism Suggest that We already Have a foregone Conclusion If we say Something like That And that We find People who Who agree With that To discount Vate Is also to Discount Then Wilberforce To discount Thomas Clarkson To discount Prince Saunders To discount So many Because that's Why we need All the accounts We need to See that people Had different Opinions of This human being If I were To say something Like Christophe Is a man Of his time I wouldn't Actually focus On the violence Which is what People usually Use that phrase To excuse He's a man Of his time In that With all his Flaws Thomas Clarkson And William Wilberforce Still think He is The greatest Humane Abolitionist Leader the world Has ever seen Not just Haiti Has ever seen Because they Are surrounded In their societies By monsters Who believe That slavery Should continue Forever And so He is a man Of his time In that he's So good That Even with all His flaws He's still Better Than most If not all Of the other World leaders At the time Especially in The Atlantic World

Patrick Jean-Baptiste I'm fascinated By when Reading Chelsea Stieber's Paper war book And yours Now Can you talk About the Voluminous Print culture In the north Compared to the south And how has That difference In output Shaped the Current scholarship In Haitian studies If at all

Marlene Daut Yeah The northern Writers Were prolific And they Created An entire Culture Of black Sovereignty That was Anti-slavery And anti-colonial And anti-racist At the same Time It's actually Remarkable When you think About it So you know When I'm Teaching my Students They often Bring up The question Of free Press Is they say Why does Christophe Think that They have A free Press When it's Very clear That the Press is State-run It's owed By the State of Haiti And then The kingdom Of Haiti And I say Because when Bernda Vatay And Christophe And other Writers are Using that Word free Press What they Mean is They can Say what They want Back to the Colonial world Powers That they Are not Silenced And hamstrung By a World of Pro-slavery And pro-colonial Apologists Right Vatay Says Remember They have Written 10,000 Volumes Freely The pro-slavery Crowd And now That we Have our Own printing Press We can Respond So the Meaning of Freedom Is not Anyone can Just say Anything they Want Anytime they Want And we Can have Dozens of Different Newspapers Which is What a Free press Has come To mean In our Current World Or at Least Most People's Conception Of it But they Mean We can Finally Tell the Truth about Slavery And colonialism About what Happened To us Because one Of the First things That happens Under Desaline In the Gazette Commercial And political Gazette Which was His paper Is that One of the First things They do Is justify To the World The revolution Expose The Leclerc Expedition Expose The horrors That happened With Napoleon's Army Genocidal Army That's what They mean When they Say that They have A free Press And so I think The reason The output Is so Voluminous Is yes To entertain The Haitian People as Well But it's Also They're Speaking To the World And they're Showing The world The way This is The way That you Create Sovereign A sovereign World Where black People can Thrive And again It's not Going to be A perfect World But I Always say What was The trajectory That was Stopped After Christophe's Death With the Indemnity This is What I This is One of The fundamental Questions Of the Book That You know I begin There To a Certain Extent At the End of The prologue And the Introduction And I And we End up Right back There At the End With the Epilogue

Patrick Jean-Baptiste So I Want to Go through His Genealogy What What you Know for A fact What's Speculative And so For So the First is You're Certain he Was born In Grenada Yes And you Mentioned Earlier He did Serve At the Battle of Savannah He was Vincent Auger Was there Rigo And Jean-Baptiste Chavann Do you Know how Old those Three were At that Time

Marlene Daut Oh that Is a Really good Question I don't Know off The top Of my Head But there We do Have their Baptismal Certificates So we Could look It up You know For all Intents and Purposes If we Needed to But I Don't Know off The top Of my Head And we Also have André Rigo's Record of Service And so We But they Were older Than him They They were Not Children He's From a Different Generation

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Was that Common back Then to Have children Serving And did Christophe Serve in A combat Role or Was he More supportive Do you Have some Ideas

Marlene Daut Yeah so I mean This is I would Say kind Of informed Speculation Well one Part is not The first Part let me Answer that Children in These roles Well we Know that Children in Quotation Marks Because what Is considered A child In this Era That we're Discussing Is not Necessarily What we Would consider A child Today Twelve Year olds Could serve In the Chasseur Volontaire Based on The documentation And the Rules As drummers Or trumpeters And so Christophe Has been Portrayed Most often As a Drummer But as I point Out in The book That may In fact Have been His official Role But the Comte Descamps Was a Very secretive Person A very Deliberative Person And during The operation That they Are carrying Out There's no Mention of A drummer First of All in The voluminous Documentation That the French Produce And various Soldiers And they Wouldn't Have wanted A drummer Because they Were trying To do Something That wouldn't Call the Attention of The British Whom they're Fighting against And that Thing that They're trying To do Initially In Savannah At the Battle of Savannah In October 1779 Is to dig These trenches Because then When they Fire They can Go and Send their Bombs And they Can go And run Behind the Trenches And what They don't Know is That the British are Also doing This and When they Have asked For some Time to Consider Conque de Stain who's The French Count who's In charge of This operation On the French side What he Agrees to Is to lay Down arms For a time And this Really allows The British To regroup And dig Their own Trenches And so While the Chasseurs Volontaires Which is What the Free men Of color Whom Christophe Was fighting With or With whom He had Been joined Up While they're Busy building Their trenches Now the British fire On them And it's Absolutely Disastrous And so many Of them are Wounded So it's Quite possible That he was That's the Moment he's Wounded Baron de Vatte Said that he Was wounded At the Battle Of Savannah And it could Have also Been during The actual Battle which Took place On October 9th 1779 Again required Secrecy because There was a False attack That was supposed To happen And then the Real attack Was supposed To follow But the British were Not fooled By the False attack And so This is why It became Murderous And was Actually a Losing battle For the French and American Patriots

Patrick Jean-Baptiste I might have Missed it Although I But I was Careful in My reading There is Some uncertainty As to how He got to Saint-Domingue After Savannah Right?

Marlene Daut Yes

Patrick Jean-Baptiste What are you Comfortable with Sharing with Us about That?

Marlene Daut Yeah so You know I tried to Be as Thorough as Possible in Terms of Documenting this Story because I found that A lot of Prior writing About Christophe Because it's So hard to Explain how He would get From various These various Locales to The other Locales right From Granada To Savannah To Cap Francais As it was Called at The time That I I followed The paths And that's Why there Are chapters On this They're not Just paragraphs As you will Find in a lot Of writings About Christophe There's chapters And I say These are the Ships We have Records of The ships I read Every single Issue of The affiche American To find out When did The ships Come home Because the Papers Documented All these Things When did The ships Come back And I Learned that The ships Were not Supposed The ships That came Back Initially Were not Destined For that That Comte de Saint Kind of Even though He's this Renowned general Kind of fell Apart there At the end And he was Shot many Times So that Might have Had something To do With it But the Ships That got Pushed Further out To sea And storms Ended up Back in Cap Francais And they were Written about In the newspapers So I follow Those ships And I say Very possible These ships That were supposed To go elsewhere In the Caribbean They ended up Back in Saint-Domingue That's how He could have Ended up Back there I also talk About some Of the Chasseurs Volontaires Who went To Paris I think It's unlikely That he was One of them But it's Always possible Went to Paris And actually Received Kind of laurels And again The newspapers Writing about This Saying Oh I wonder What the Parisians Think of All these Free men Of color Walking around In their Society Getting You know Accolades For fighting In this war And then They returned Later To Saint-Domingue And it's Also possible That like André Rigaud Who was To Saint-Domingue His main rival That Christophe Could have Served Elsewhere In the Caribbean Before returning To Saint-Domingue As Rigaud Did because We do have His service Record So we can See all The various Islands That he Served On In between Savannah And then You know Kind of Re-establishing Himself On the island And becoming Part of A Haitian Revolution

Patrick Jean-Baptiste His future Life Marie-Louise You discovered That she Wasn't born With the Last name Of Quadavid But of Malgrin

Marlene Daut Absolutely

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Can you Talk about That

Marlene Daut Yes I do Want to Say I I don't Want to Say I Discovered This Because I have Danielle Suppis' Dictionnaire Biographique And I Did I Didn't Remember This At the Time I Found The Document But I Had Consulted The book For other Things After After I Found it And as I was Going over Her entry He uses That last Name But he Does Not say Where he Got it From As one Of her Last Names So In So This is A note This is Sort of Known But not Known But I Would Say I Documented This Last Name Because Again At the Time When I Found This These Documents Where she Is signing Her name She's Using the Name Malgrin She's Clearly Known By that Name In the Colony Most People Don't Seem to Have Most Other Researchers Don't Seem to Have Ever Come Across These Documents I've Never Seen Them Cited Anywhere Or Referred To Anywhere But I Think There Was There Is Some Common Knowledge In Haiti That She Had Another Last Name Which Is Again Another Kind of Fascinating Piece Because There Is Or There Are A lot Of Oral Historical Kind of Claims In The Book Where Somebody Whose Ancestor Told Somebody Else Something And I Wanted To Take Those Things Seriously As Well Because A lot Of Times Those Things Were Absolutely Corrupt Could Be Documented And I Think That This Issue Of Malgrin Is Potentially Another One Of Those

Patrick Jean-Baptiste There Is Another Beautiful Passage In Your Book Out Of Many You Talk About Resistance And This Is Me Paraphrasing The Face Of Unconscionable Evil You Mentioned Malonards I Think Laying Bear The Fiction Of White Supremacy And Inalienable Infrastructure Is What I'm Calling It That No Matter How Different Ways The French Operationalized Oppression Our Ancestors Pushback Can You Talk About Resistance

Marlene Daut Oh Yeah I Mean Certain Parts Of This Book I Think I Went Into Various Fugue States Because I Just I Was Feeling So Deeply The People Who Kept Running Away That The French Called Maroons In The New That's The French Used And They Kept Running Away No Matter What They're These Very Evil People Because It's The Only Way To Describe Them It Is Absolutely Unconscionably Evil They Are You Know Not Just Whipping And Branding People They're Like Cutting Things Off They're Doing Terrible Things That Are Just Objectively Terrible And They're Still Running Away And In Fact One Of The Stories That Didn't Make It Into The Book It Was It Seems

!

Marlene Daut About Somebody Who Could Be Related To Kristoff Or Something He Could Have Experienced But There I Found Accounts Of Young Girls Seven And Eight Running Away Preferring A Life In The Wilderness And The Mountains Alone To Being On A Plantation And I Can't I Cannot Fathom I Don't Want To Fathom What Is Happening That Someone With A Child So Young Would Prefer The There Was Group Paronage Where You Would Sometimes See Families Escaping Or Units They Would Necessarily Say There Is A Woman She Is 32 There Is A Man He Is 40 And There Three Children Or Something And You Can Maybe Assume They're A Unit Or At Least They Go Together But The Ones Where She Was Ten Or Even The Boys He Was ! That Spirit Of Resisting When They Said Liberty Or Death They Meant It In Ways Again That I Think Are Really Unfathomable To Most People And Again I Wanted When I Write About This Potentially One Day I Want To Honor These Stories In A Way I Don't Want It To Be A Side Note On The Way To Something Else Because It Deserves A Lot Of Meditation And Reflection To Think About Deep Levels Not Just The Freedom Fighters The Traditional Freedom Fighters But The Maroons And What They Went Through And What They Carried To Just Resist And Say I'm Not Going To Live This Way And If This Is What Life Is Then I'll Find I'll Take My Chances In Another World

Patrick Jean-Baptiste It's June 8 1801 Christophe Is Promoted The Brigadier General I Want You To Give Us A Sense Of His Personal And Professional Sort Of Key Milestones In His Life So Because I'm Thinking From Enslaved Child All The Way Up To Brigadier General In The French

Marlene Daut Army That's Pretty Incredible

Patrick Jean-Baptiste How Did Such A Meteoric Rise Shape The Outlook As A Man Husband And Warrior Because I Always Think That Kind ! Of Social Mobility In Such An Extreme Fashion Tend To Reveal Both The Strengths And Weaknesses Of A Person Yeah

Marlene Daut It's Clear That So He Becomes A Businessman Christophe Does He Gets Married He Forms The Free Black Family He Has Children With His Wife Marie Louise And He Begins To Work For In So This Is The Period Where Slavery The Freedom Fire Have Forced The Franks To Abolish Slavery So We're Talking About After The Haitian Revolution Has Begun And Then There's This Interim Period From 1794 To If We Just Go To 1801 But Really From 8 To 1802 When The Leclerc Expedition Gets There Where A Lot Of Black Men Experienced Forms Of Social Mobility That Are Actually Quite Astonishing For This Time Period Because We Are Not Just Talking About Oh You're A Rich Plantation Owner Or Something We're Talking About Enslaved People Desalines As Well But Plenty Of Others And This Rise Is Really Meteoric I Don't Know Any Other Way To Describe It Because It Is They Are The People In Society Whose Chance To Survive Is So Limited Remember The Death Rate Those Born In The Colony Don't Live Past 15 Or 16 And This Is From The French Government's Own Documentation That Those Forcibly Transported There Won't Live More Than Two Or Three Years So For Them To Someone Like To Just Survive Slavery And Also Survive It In I Can't Say They Weren't Broken ! They Decided They Decided To Live Life To Its Fullest And They All Became Businessmen To A Certain Extent They Ran Free Plantations That Were Supposed To Be Worked By Free Hands And Deserves We need To think About that In between Time period More We need Big sweeping Histories But we also Need Histories Of that Time period Because Women As well There Are Plenty Of Women As Well Suzanne Leverture Toussaint Leverture's Wife And so Seeing What forms Of social Mobility Were Available To Various Different Kinds Of People Is You know Is a Question That we Can be Asking From This Period 1794 To 1802 And Perhaps It is Because Of that Highly Visible Social Mobility That The French React So Strongly And Want To Bring It Down Even Though They're The Ones Who Sanction It Legally Speaking

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Maybe I'm not Caracaristing It Right Here But In Chapter Six You Seem Particularly

!

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Critical Of 35 Year Old Ish Christoph's Professional And Personal Decision Baking That Was An Interesting Chapter You Said His Ambition Blinded Him To The Point Where He Wasn't Able To See The Consequences Of His Action And How It Affected Those Around Him You Mentioned Two Tragic Mistakes What Were

Marlene Daut Two Leading Into 1803 Yes But So the First one Is And they Are As I Talk about In the Book They Don't Happen Exactly At The Same Time But They You Can Sort Of Think Of Them As One Mistake So The First one Is That Of Course Christophe Is Famous For You Know Having Cap Francais Set On Fire When The Leclerc Expedition Gets There Toussaint Vierctur Is Kind Of Upset With Him About This Because They Both Get Declared Outlaws Because Christophe Is In Charge Of Cap Francais And Of Course Toussaint Vierctur Is Governor General Of The Colony So He's Got To Fall On His Sword For This And Then As The Fighting Gets Really Terrible Right So I Mean These Are People Who I Mean They've Just Been At War So Much They Hardly Had Any Peace Through March And April Christophe Starts To Listen To Various Generals Some Of Who Are His Friends Like Commander Vilton When And He Starts To Listen To This And He Says Give Me Proof And They Give Him Proof Which Is Not Exactly What He Asks For But They Say Look Claire Signed This And Says Everybody Is Going To Be Free Here And There's Not Going Any Distinctions Based On Color Or Anything Like That And So Christophe Says Okay Well I'll Join Back Up With You And I'll Convinced Toussaint I Do So As Well And He Does He Writes To Toussaint He Says We've Got To Go Back Into The Father Land Arms We've Got To Stop Fighting Against Ourselves Because In All These Battles They'll Notice That They're Killing People And Fighting Against People Who Were Fighting With Them In The Freedom Struggle Earlier ! Abstract It's Easy To See It As Oh Yeah He Just Decides To Join With The French Because He Betrays Toussaint Vibrature Or Because He's A Traitor To The Cause Of Liberty But If You Think About It From His Letters Which I Quote He Says We're Killing People We Know Like We Can Either Try To Turn To Our Side But If They Don't What Are We Do The French Army And Then Infamously Of The French Under Brunet Who's Really A Terrful Character In This Tricks Him Has Him Deported Arrested And In 1803 Dies This Terrible Death In France One Of The Things That I Think Influenced Christophe In This Decision Was That You Know The French Could Dangle The Promise Of We'll Let Your Child Go To France To Be Educated Because That's What A Lot Of Free Black Men Wanted And Christophe Had A Makeshift School That He Set Up On One Of The Plantations So He Was Very Interested In Education And One Of His eldest Son François Ferdinand Who He Called Ferdinand To Be Educated And So Unfortunately Around This Time Period He Commits His Son To Go To France And When Christophe Later Learns He Defects To The Army And Dijen That's Going To Be Set Up And Run Under Desalines But It's Too Late His Child Is In France And As Soon As Haitian Independence Is Declared The Initial Independence In November 1803 I Mean They The French Shut Down This School They Throw His Child Into An Orphanage He Ends Up In The Streets Of Parish Where He Dies This Horrible Terrible Death And So Just You Know There's This Kind Of Sad Parallel With What Happened To Tucson Virtue Even Though Their Experiences Their Ages Everything About The Two Cases Couldn't Have Been More Different But They Die This Same Miserable Death In France

Patrick Jean-Baptiste And It Was Sad You Had A Scene Where The Son Was Pleading That My Father Sent Money I'm Not Depending On The French State For This

Marlene Daut It's So Sad I Honestly The Only Way That I Can Fathom It Sometimes Is Christophe Does He Think They He Thinks That Evil People The Evil French People Are In The Colony You Know I Have This Article Called All The Devils Are Here Like It's There's Something About The Way That Toussaint And Christophe In Particular Write ! Read Two Transmissives He I'm Going To Explain To You What If You Only Knew What Was Happening Back Here And They Don't Realize That Not All The Devils Are In The Colony They're All They're All Over Europe And They Support Slavery And They're Going To Uphold It And They're In The Government And Their Faith That There's Rationality Back In France Is Something That's Hard For Us To Fathom Because We See Through It So Clearly ! Because We Have Hindsight And We Have Exactly The Perspective They Couldn't Have

Patrick Jean-Baptiste It Doesn't Seem This All Suffered Most Gladly In That Compared To The Other Two

Marlene Daut Yes And No You Know I Write About In The It's Really Hard To Know He's A bit Inscrutable Because You He Stays The Longest He Stays After Pétion And Christophe Fighting For The French And If You Could See I'm Doing Air Quotes Right Because They Are Also Complaining That He's Not Really On Their Side But He's Saying That He's On Their Side So They Decide To Try To Trick Him Leclerc Shortly Before His Death ! We're Going ! To Arrest Césaline And First Of Leclerc This One I Know This One Doesn't Really Like That One I'm Going To Get Moise Involved Here Or You Know This Is When He's Still Back In France When Moise Is Still Alive He's Saying I've Got This Entire Thing Worked Out What We're Going To Do Is We're Going To Pit Them All Against Each Other And That Seems To Have Worked To The People Who Say But Now We Don't Trust You Because That Form Of Inscrutability That Desaline Used A lot Of Times I Think That Worked Against Him As Well Because Okay Maybe The French Don't Know If You're Really For Them Or Against Them But The Other Freedom Fighters Absolutely Needed Reassurance That Desaline Christophe While He Was Still Alive While He Was Still Alive They Needed The

Enemy

Marlene Daut And So I Don't I Think That Inscrutability Is You Know Perhaps This Would Be A Question For Julia Gaffield To Ask Her If She Thinks That Was Maybe One Of His Main Flaws Was Not Revealing Enough Not Revealing Enough Even Though It Seems Like In His Speeches He Does We Have To Remember There Are People Who Remember Otherwise He Says This But They know what happened during the revolutionary period because it wasn't that long ago. And I think that's

Patrick Jean-Baptiste also true of Christophe. You put the word, the Dessalines massacre, and quotes as well too throughout chapter eight. You were pretty consistent in that. Talk to us about that, why you had a problem with that word, and compare the French terrorism with Leclerc Rochambeau versus what allegedly Dessalines did. Yeah, I mean, it's interesting because,

Marlene Daut you know, you start to, first of all, what gets to be a massacre, right? That I find that when black people kill white people, it's a massacre. It's terrorism. You know, when non-white people, it's terrorism. But I mean, the French massacred people every day on that island. And Jean Casimir says something really interesting in the documentary, Independence or Death, the history hit documentary. He says, it's not just Leclerc being, and Napoleon being genocidal and Rochambeau. The whole operation, all of slavery, this is a genocidal operation. And so who gets to be, you know, we don't want to, I don't, I even hate to use the word victim, but who gets to have the world's sympathy on their side to use the strong words. And so I felt that, especially since there's so much that we still don't know about the alleged massacres, that it would be unfair to just use that word in an unthinking way. Especially since I go through and document so much of what the French were doing, based on eyewitness accounts from foreigners and from other French people, from the British as well, that this is, people are pretty clear, they're drowning, the French are drowning people in the fall of 1802. They're using dogs by the spring of 1803. They are absolutely desperate. And they are, Rochambeau is writing home and he's saying, I'm just going to kill all of them and we can repopulate this colony. This is not a question that these are the intentions. He of course lacks the means to carry out, which is why it didn't happen. But I think that we need to pay attention to what else were called genocidal imaginings, especially by powerful people, because what's the line? If Napoleon had just sent more troops faster with better provisions and better outfitting, you know, then would it have been complete? And so with the massacres, what we see is there's a lot of disagreement about, is this a continuation of the war? Are these white French people trying to overthrow the now independent Haitian government after 1804? Or are these wonton executions for revenge or just a bloodthirst? There are so many different opinions. And again, foreigners alike saying, no, that's not true. That's not what happened. These people were trying to overthrow the government. And so again, to just use that word and throw that out there, I think would do disservice to the fact that there's still a lot that we need to, we still have to learn and study and think about more because the answers might never be clear cut. But I always say, you know, is it that we want to know or do we want to understand? Because those are two different projects. And I think for me, I try to understand what people are going through and the decisions that they made, not so that we defend them. But again, so we understand so that when we narrate these stories, we do so, I think we have to from a place of compassion, because there are real people who died and suffered, and they're not all on one side. There's so there's enough suffering to go

Patrick Jean-Baptiste around in this story. We're going to do a little bit of Latin. My Latin's a little rusty. You said, you, nec cluribus impar, which you translated as not unequal to many. My old Latin teacher will probably, you know, whack me on the left hand, but I translated it as equal to many tasks. I know you mentioned the Latin phrasing, I think, later on to talk about Christophe's crowning. But when I translated it as equal to many tasks, I immediately marveled at how many tasks that Christophe had under the Saline beyond his military duties. I mean, he was basically an event manager for the celebration of January 1st, right? So, and this all seemed like prep for his effectiveness as a king later on in terms of education, a lot of the sort of structural and infrastructure change that he made later. Can you talk about that? The Saline just kept dumping more on him. Yeah, I like that you

Marlene Daut pointed that out, because he's this big general in chief of the army. And, and they're like, can you please plan the celebration for Independence Day? Right? And he does. He's writing to the Empress, Mappi Claire, to Desaline's wife. And he's saying, Oh, I've got you this. And I got this, like, sugar she wanted. And I got all this stuff that you've asked for. And then even later in the very last celebration under Desaline, he's still dealt, he's delegate, you go here, you go there. So he's delegating, he's doing all of these things. And he's running, as you said, he's trying to set up a school system. He's trying to look for young boys who could be apprentices at the printer shop. And they've got to go to the schooling first that he sets up for them so they can learn orthography and learn how to spell it and do and have good penmanship. And, and he's doing all of these things while he's also a father. He had he and Desaline's children, his and Desaline's children share a caretaker. He's also in charge of the legal system. So when terrible things happen, or people are not behaving and by terrible things, I mean, there, there are some things I cut out of the book is again, I didn't want some of the stories to be distracting. But for example, you know, they had these really strong laws against rape. And so when things like that would happen, they would crack down the arm of justice. And so we see those letters reflected as well. Thiefs, people who stole things, you can see that I think when people didn't have things for so long, they react very strongly to others taking their things in a way that I think today we would say, okay, well, you know, should you really cut off someone's hand if they steal something, you know, I mean, we would have a different perspective. But in their world, these are grave, this is a grave crime, and it deserves to be punished. Other things that were grave crimes were, you know, sedition. So there's at one point in the book, I talk about on New Year's Eve, some men are getting drunk, and somebody reports that they hear them sort of plotting or saying bad things about the emperor. And so Christoph gets six reports. So yes, he's and he's got to, you know, figure out what to do. And, and should they be harshly punished? Or was it where they just intoxicated and they should be let go? And then at the same time, the citadel, what becomes the citadel Henri, today the citadel La Ferrière, is under construction clearly during Desalines' reign. And Christoph is overseeing that too. And we see him doing everything from ordering more laborers to go up there or, and ordering soldiers to go up there to ordering nails and bricks and things. But he's really in charge of many food for the hospitals, linens for the hospitals. He is reporting to Desalines when, about when he's learning various information from Rouenet, the printer, about the embargo that he thinks is going to be passed in the United States against Haiti, and which is in fact passed, and what should they do about it? And should Rouenet print this information in the newspapers? I mean, so he is, he is equal to many tasks, which I think makes him not unequal to many. So I'll say, I'll say it like that.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Capua l'amour. Oh, yes. Give us a sense of his relationship with Christophe and Desalines.

Marlene Daut Yes, this is, I mean, there are so many painful parts because, you know, you're not writing, like if you're writing a novel, you can decide, well, I don't want this character to do this, or I don't want them to do that, right? And so Capua l'amour, François Capua and Christophe are friends. And, but Capua, Capua, he has a different perspective on, on, on life in Haiti after the colonial era. So he's, Christophe is in charge of the whole army. He makes Capua a high-ranking official. He gives him these various tasks, but really from the beginning of Haitian independence, he's got reason to reprimand Capua, who is famous for being Capua l'amour, who's en avant during the battle of Vertières, the hero of Vertières. But he also clearly loves him because he, you know, peppers his letter with these kind of affectionate phrases, which doesn't do with everyone. And he says, you know, come on, we thought, I need you to just kind of fall in line. Can you do that for me? And I think even at the very end, before Capua disappears, and dies, most likely, not to be seen again, Christophe is saying, if you don't want to be in the military anymore, if you're done with this, you need to tell me because, you know, things are coming to a head here. And, and then his tragic end, of course, is that, you know, he gets himself, Capua does caught up in this, these various rebellions that were happening against Desalines' rule. And he's essentially never heard from it again, just a few days before Desalines' assassination, shortly before the assassination.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste So there's no proof that Christophe killed Capua?

Marlene Daut He didn't kill him with his own hands. But, you know, so in the book, I set up, these are the people that he sent to go and talk to him. And then he sent for the ed du camp of, of the two ed du camp of Capua, and they showed up and Capua didn't. So, and then he, Christophe, gave someone else Capua's like duties. So it was, and then referred, he's referred to in these letters, these 18, late 1806, October 1806 letters, as Capua, you know, for Capua, like the late Capua. So he's, they, they understand him to be dead. And this is important also because when other high-ranking, highly esteemed generals from the revolution die, they are ordering, you know, gun salutes and mourning for days and like all these things. And then he dies and it's like, nothing. So, you know, he doesn't say the traitor as he will about, you know, people from the Southern Republic later, but, but he certainly is this, there's not occasion to mourn this for them. And which suggests that they viewed this as a righteous thing. At this moment in time, they are just trying to rid the island of traitors, internal and external and spies and things like

Patrick Jean-Baptiste that who had come into the empire. Who is responsible for this Alin's death?

Marlene Daut Petio claimed responsibility, but you know, it's actually astonishing to me that, I don't know how I want to phrase this. It's astonishing to me that this was a question, except that, you know, I also approached it as a question because I didn't want to approach it in a foregone way where then you find, you know, things that, that, that, that support that conclusion and you maybe disregard things that don't. So I followed, because in that chapter, in the assassination chapter, I could have just said, here's what happened, right? But I wanted to follow Christophe's day initially, because I felt like that would really help people to understand since in so much of the post-Dessaline assassination writing Christophe was blamed. I wanted to follow his day and I wanted to follow how it is that he became associated with this, which is even the Southerners say, okay, fine. He wasn't in on the assassination, but he was in on the, he was in on the coup, like, or he knew about it enough that he wasn't going to stop it. So that's, I think, the part where we still have the question mark, because when we follow his day, he seems very astonished. But if we, if you follow the thread of that chapter all the way through, right, to the next part where they, the, the victors, in this case, Southerners, they start to try to tell the story, which of course they're going to try to spin. It is very interesting that they say, no, our goal was never to kill the emperor, because of course, that would have been a violation of the constitution. We were going to use this obscure article that says that he sets up a system of nobility, essentially, these kind of distinctions, because the constitution, that constitution says that you can't have distinctions, right, other than merits, virtues, talents, that bit of thing, that they use that to say that they could depose him. But that he came in, Desauline came in hot, is essentially their, their argument, with all these soldiers and everything, and he came in hot and ready for a fight, and that they had no choice. So that's their story. And you can see why they would want to tell this story, because even if Desauline is as unpopular as they claim he is, and he could very well be very unpopular in the South, right, because they're, the Southerners are sort of amping up the people saying, you know, he's doing this and he's doing that. But the idea of killing your head of state, well, this might be a bridge too far, because the revolutionaries were decrying that the French barbarity had led them to behead their own king, right? Because like, this is a mark against them. These are barbaric people who do this type of thing. So, so there's some contradictory attitudes. And, and that's important to remember that not everyone would share the same attitude. Because again, even if some people don't like Desauline, or don't agree with his rule, it doesn't follow that they necessarily want him to be assassinated. Because that's, that is a bridge that's like so much further away than just saying, let's have a conversation about it, and how we want to be governed, and how we want to be ruled, and what we should do about this situation. And, and so that story of this being kind of an accidental, but ultimately good outcome, to use Pétion's words, that's the story that the Southerners tell.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste I want to talk about pens and projectiles, or bullets and pamphlets, the Civil War. There's a lot going on in chapter 11. But I'm, I think probably the best way to kind of frame it, so you can give us a good summary, is to just look at, and you did it for me, and I appreciate that, not for me

Marlene Daut directly, but you know, the constitutions. Yes.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste The 1801 constitution officially named Louverture as governor general, the Saline's 1805 constitution named him emperor, but the newly minted Republic of Haiti constitution in December 1806 did not mention Christoph as the head of state. So let's start there, to tell that story of how it all started, the Civil War started.

Marlene Daut Yeah. So the Southerners make Christoph pretty quickly interim head of state, but without any other kind of title describing what, you know, the country's going to be like after this. And, you know, this complicated situation happens with how they're going to form this constitution and who's going to be involved. But it turns out that Christoph does, in fact, get elected to be president. The Southerners admit this, because again, I wanted to follow each thread, not just what I wanted to see what was the actual process. And so he becomes president, but because the Southerners, with some delegates from the North supposedly, although that's the origin of the Civil War is that supposedly those delegates from the North were not allowed really to participate in the making of this constitution, that they set up a republic. And they say that they want it to have three branches, legislative, judicial, and executive, after the model of the United States, although their voting system does not work in how it is in the constitution as the voting system worked in the United States. It works more like Republican France. But if we put that aside for a second, they say they've set up this republic. And because it's a republic, modeled after the United States, the head of state, the president, is supposed to turn over. So in that light, the constitution wouldn't name the president, right? Just as it doesn't in the United States, because that president is going to change over time, which is very different from an emperor who's going to rule for life, or a king who's going to rule for life, that if you had a constitutional monarchy, that would be stated in there. And then it would say how the successor is going to be chosen, which is what de Salien's 1805 constitution did. And so this is troubling to Christophe. The situation with the northern delegates is troubling to him. And he decides that he's not going to appear in the south in Port-au-Claas to take his oath. And he leads a strike against the Southerners. And this leads to the 13-year civil war, essentially.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste So now let's fast forward to June 2nd, 1811, Christophe's crown, and what you describe as a world full of kings. Napoleon is emperor. Rigolo returns to Haiti after, I think, about 10 years, right? Absence?

Marlene Daut Seven years. Seven years.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste Seven years. Okay. Kate, you are not too happy about that. So what did Napoleon have to do with the state of

Marlene Daut Haiti becoming the kingdom in the north? Well, the northerners are absolutely convinced that Napoleon has sent him back because they are saying to themselves, there is no way this man has escaped from this country. Because initially, when Rigaud is deported definitively from the island, so Leclerc, depends on your point of view whether it was a mistake or not, lets him come back during the Leclerc expedition. And Rigaud has no intention of following the directive he's given, which is no contact with people in Lekai, where he's from. So that's not going to happen, obviously. You're not in trouble with anybody, with Toussaint-Vertre, with anybody. And he starts to start trouble, and so they deport him. And he initially goes to the jail where Toussaint-Vertre is eventually, where Toussaint-Vertre is imprisoned. But Toussaint-Vertre is already dead by the time Rigaud gets there. But to get himself out of the jail, I believe that, so we know he wrote a pamphlet, which was common at the time, that are these reconquest pamphlets, plans for how the French can retake their colony. And he writes this pamphlet and gets himself free-ish. But the French sent him to various places, and he has the city for a prison in these places. And he's surveilled. He lives off of a French pension, but all his letters are read. And in Haiti, back now in independent Haiti, as the years wear off, they get reports from various people coming and going. And so they know this, that Rigaud cannot return. He is not allowed to return. He is detained. He is surveilled. He is under constant watch. So not imprisoned, per se, but he's under constant watch. And so they are thinking, there's no way that Napoleon just said, oh, now I believe everything's fine. You can just go there. And then they get reports that he was in the United States, which was true, that he met with the consul general of France in Philadelphia, that this consul general, this is what they believe, gave him money and allowed him to return back to Haiti. The French still call Saint-Domingue. So it allowed him to return back and that his goal must be to overthrow the government. And if you think about it from the northerner's perspective, when Rigaud gets there, what does he do? He tries to be in charge. And it leads to a scission between him and Pétion, and they have to come to an agreement, which further shrinks the Southern Republic, the part that's under Pétion's command. Because Rigaud now has Les Cayes and this entire swath of the peninsula under his control. And Pétion, you know, to the northerners, to hear the northerners tell it, they say he really just has Port-au-Place in its kind of our surrounding area. And so back in the kingdom, they're saying, if this place is so fragile, the Republic, that Rigaud can return, he still has tons of enemies, but he has tons of allies and family members, his son, other people who love him, who served under him, and can do this so easily, we need to work on, you know, what form of governance we're going to have. They were the state of Haiti at that point. Christophe was president and generalissimo of the forces of the earth and seas of the state of Haiti. And now they say the councillors of state who are supposed to make a new constitution say, we want you to become king. And they decide that in March 1811, on June 2nd of that year, he's crowned.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste So like the good professor that you are, you asked your reader to memorize three French spies, to memorize these names. We're June 1814 now. And I couldn't memorize them. It's Augustine Franco de Medina, Jean-François d'Auxien Lavais, and Herman de Ravelma. Three French spies. Why are these three names so important for us to remember?

Marlene Daut So we can also add the term to remember French hubris. I think when people, you know, and I love, I love teaching this actually to students that I do, because they are like, wait, give me a break here. So Napoleon goes into exile the first time. And he's in exile on the island of Elba. And the Bourbons come back to power. Louis XVIII comes back to power to get his brother's throne, Robert Louis XVI has been executed. And one of the first things he does is decide, I'm going to send these spies to Saint-Domingue, which is what they persist in calling it, to pave the way for the reinstatement of slavery. And under the French minister of the Marine, a man named Malouet, whose name is hated in all of Haiti at this time, he gives them instructions. And he tells them, burn these instructions after reading them. But, you know, just like, hello, we can't remember all these bullet point instructions. They were very long about who was supposed to go where and who was supposed to do what. And so the idea was some of them were supposed to go to the Republic and talk to Petion and Bourgela, one of his right-hand men, because they are, quote unquote, lighter skinned mulattos, and they'll be on our side. And sure, we're going to screw them over later too, but right now we need to get them on our side. The person we really need to mess with is Christophe. And Petion is going to help us do that. So we're going to talk to him first. But Petion, surprisingly, he listens to them, but he's like, no, and reminds them of what they did. And I was actually surprised by that because the Northerners tell the story, you know, Petion is, you know, completely willing to let the French come back, which is not true, but he does want independence and, or rather for independence to be recognized. And so Petion, unfortunately, concocts this scheme where, no, we're not going to become a French colony again, but maybe we could pay you something. And the Northerners get wind of this and they just kind of lose their minds like, no, we're never, ever going to do that. And so this plot doesn't work. The spies have to go away. Christophe kills one of them, we think. He at least detains him in this chapter you're talking about with this living wake he gives him and then imprisons him and the man's never heard from again. But when Napoleon returns for his 100 days, the Haitian people are like, what on earth is going on over there? This man escaped from an island in the middle of the sea. He showed back up in Paris. All the troops the king sent to go stop him, then ended up joining with him. What's happening over there? So Napoleon rules again for 100 days. But then when he's again overthrown in 1815 and Louis XVIII is able to return to his throne, this man, this French king tries again. And the Haitian people are incredulous during this time period and the government is incredulous. And they publish all the stories detailing all the plots and all the things that the French king is trying to do. And I think that this really wins the court. Christophe really wins the court of public opinion, not just in Haiti, but in the United States and in Great Britain. Because they hate Napoleon over in Great Britain just as much as if not more than the Haitians. They call them all kinds of names. They've been in these long wars with him. But they also can't imagine that the French would want to send more of their own soldiers to go and die in what they consider as a feudal mission. They have reports from the Kingdom of Haiti and the Republic, and they know that both places are thriving. And they can't possibly imagine why the French would want to waste their time doing that. So that's kind of the stalemate where they are at the end of the spying and delegation episodes.

Patrick Jean-Baptiste How would you characterize Pétion's role in all of this? Did the French just see him as sort of a foil for Christophe? Or, I mean, he didn't seem to characterize him as sort of this puppet willingly going along with the French. Did I miss something there? Or what would you put his role in there as the French twice, right? Under Louis XVIII trying to re-enslave? Where would you put him historically?

Marlene Daut Yeah, no, I don't think that Pétion is a puppet in that sense. I don't think that at all, actually. Because I do think, again, reading his missives with the various French delegations, the spies, and then these supposed commissioners who are sent to the island during the second Bourbon restoration. And, you know, they say, we don't want to hear anything more about what happened under Napoleon. We don't like that guy either. Hello, we overthrew him, but we don't want to hear anything more about it. And Pétion was like, no, you don't get to not hear anything more about it. I'm going to remind you that that's why we don't want to be French. And so, you know, this next set of commissioners during the second Bourbon restoration say, you know, and I talk about in the book how easily the French turn to that language of, okay, we'll just kill you all, the language of violence. Because at first, like, oh, we like you so much. Oh, general, because they're not going to call him president. Oh, general, oh, we esteem you and everything. And then as soon as he says, well, no, you're going to, you need to listen to our grievances and complaints. They say, okay, well, when bad things happen and all your people disappear, then it will be your own fault that you didn't come back into the loving arms of the Bourbons. Right. And so I was actually really surprised, reading this, that there was a level of compromise that Petion was willing to enter into. He was saying, okay, we'll pay you something to go away. We will, we will have some treaties with you. I'll even let you come onto the island. I'll listen to you. This was really different from Christophe's approach. Christophe's approach was, we will not negotiate with you if you call me general, if you call this islands and domain, if you send people here who use those terms and say that we are negotiating with a mother country because you're not our mother country and that we would negotiate and we will not pay you any money. So he has these, these terms, which are very different from Petion is kind of like, whatever you're calling me this potentially it personally irritated him, but I think he was possibly thinking about, well, if the goal is to get recognition, then, you know, I can humor you. But the thing he wasn't going to humor the French was with this idea of, oh, we're going to become a part of France again, in some way, shape or form for that. He was, it was a definite no for him, but there were other things that he was willing to entertain at least, but so he wasn't a puppet. He was just a little bit more flexible than Christophe on certain points. You called Christophe a complicated

Patrick Jean-Baptiste anti-hero. What did you mean by that? Can you flesh that out for us? Yeah. You know, I think,

Marlene Daut I feel like people will be able, I hope to understand how the world could root for somebody who today people say, I don't know, because we have a lot, we have a lot of ideas that we have exacting standards of what we think about for humanity. Right. But the world also does still, to my mind, understand anti-heroes because I see them all over the television. I see them all over, like that show Dexter, where I'm like, oh, people are really out here rooting for a serial killer because it's like the avenging, right? Like he's doing his path. But then, but then what happens at the end of that series, because I admit I watched it too, is, oh, when, when does the step get taken a little too far though? When does it become not about those other people? And when do you become not an Avenger, but now you are somewhat of, I don't want to use the term executioner because I think it's a really strong word that could be taken in an inflammatory way. But I will say that being an, that's what an anti-hero is. It's the, they think they are doing right. And I think that's what distinguishes an anti-hero from just an absolute tyrant or despot is along the way, even at the end. And if I would say that's at the end of Christoph's life, what surprises me is he, sure, he, he, according to his doctor, he feels bad about things and he realizes he could have done things differently, but he's, he can't understand why the people don't get that. He just wanted to cement freedom, that he just wanted what was best for them. And every time people are acting up, I should say, or acting out for lack of a better phrase, when he's punishing them, he's kind of like, why are you doing this? Can't you just follow these rules? I want to set up this good society that where we can all be protected. And, but, but that is, that is a certain kind of language of tyranny. Like everything would be fine if you just do what I say, right? Because that can lead to abuse because a lot of people end up believing sort of in their own greatness and their, and, and the idea that he's the only one who can do it. And I think when he got to the point where he thought I'm the only one, I'm your savior. Oh, that was where I saw things start to, because once you've set it up that way, all the people trying to not follow you are just enemies, people who don't know what's good for them. And that those are dangerous views to hold that when you're trying to lead a country, especially a country of people who've already

Patrick Jean-Baptiste suffered so much, so, so much. I was talking to a friend of mine about this book and King Henry's legacy. And she said to me that materially, he left edifices like Sanssouci and the Citadelle that still exists to this day. And, and she wondered what, what will the current leadership in Haiti leave us 221 years later. So this is what you wrote. The story of King Henry reveals a proud, determined, and self-sufficient country whose culture was mired around the world. That quote contrasts with today, where Haiti is a hollowed out, a dependent state, the, you know, the, you know, the disaster, capitalism on and on and on. Talk about the, as you were going through this book and looking at its accomplishments and, and how unapologetic in a lot of instances, these founders were.

Marlene Daut It's, I think it's more relevant now than I can ever imagine. The Julia Gaffield's Gesselin book, I think that you studying this time period and what everyone was doing. I know a lot of people are writing about Haitian women, revolutionaries and freedom fighters from various institutions. But before even sort of entertaining the kind of current day question, I would say Haiti's culture is still admired around the world. The world that these freedom fighters, because Christophe didn't do it alone. Desalines didn't do it alone as much as they said. Marie Claire, Desalines's wife, is responsible for this culture of celebrating January 1st Independence Day celebrations, of having feasts, of having feasts, of all of that. These things that are admired around the world today are legacies of the, the post-independence period. The culture of theater and dance that we see really strongly in Christophe's era of literature. Can you think of a country that has suffered so much with such admired writers, a country in the state of Haiti? Edouard Glissant, the Martinican kind of poet and theorist and playwright. He said, it is astonishing to see what the Haitians are doing. And then the question is, can a people be purely and simply annihilated in this way? They're producing a beautiful art, a culture, music, food, a literature, and being annihilated in this way. And this to me is, is perhaps the painful contradiction laid bare is that all the beauty, all the culture, it, we still need to live. People still need to live. They need the basics of existence. All of it is beautiful, but the country has to be functioning and running and it can't be sold. And I don't know if Desalines and Christophe and even Pétion would have been able to hold off the French. I don't know that. And nobody knows that from the identity. But what we do know is that things drastically changed under Boyer because even when you look at the rural code, that language of strong citizens is, no, you are now laborers. Like changing that language, changing that language is such a watershed moment. And, and it's hard for me to say that that is so far in the past, it doesn't have anything to do with what's happening right now, but the way that rulers view their people as in Haiti, as people who can be used as collateral damage, the lack of concern for human life is not actually from the era of this period. It's not actually from the era of the founding, from the post-revolutionary era, from the kingdom of Haiti. They don't speak about the people like that. Absolutely not. They, they say they love them and they want good things for them. And again, even if their actions don't always lead to that, wouldn't necessarily lead us to draw that conclusion, they would never behave in the way, or they didn't behave in the way, I should say, that more contemporary rulers have. Even when we look at Desalines Duvalier and Tonton Macout, this level of brutality was not wielded against the Haitian

Patrick Jean-Baptiste people in this era in this systematic way. The book is The First and Last King of Haiti, The Rise and Fall of Henry Christophe. And speaking of cultural production, I hope to have you and Dr. Glover in to talk about the history of Dacia literature. Oh, that would be wonderful. To have the dynamic duo together and under one show, it's going to be fun. Any last thoughts?

Marlene Daut Thank you so much for your thorough reading and care of this time period. You know, people always ask me, well, why, why should we study this and this time period? And I think because I always say this is the era of strong sovereignty and independence. And I mean that as a, as a, the opposite of dependence in that sense. And what can we learn from it? I think we, there's plenty of things to learn. And they're, they're the lessons that, to Saint-Denis-Denis-Cherlor, when you negotiate with constituted authority that wants your destruction, you're just negotiating your own destruction. And Christophe and Desalines and the other freedom fighters learned that and they tried to create something different. And it hasn't worked yet, but that does not mean that it won't work in the future. We have to believe that. Thank you.